Arbitration awards
-
2009
-
Case Number
Parties Involved
Nature of dispute
Award / Outcome
Applicant
Respondent
N. Mhlanga
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Application dismissed.
- No cost order was made.
- In favour of the respondent.
M.T. Coetzee
WCED
Main Issue:
Alleged Unfair Discrimination
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Application dismissed.
- No cost order was made.
- In favour of the respondent.
L. Visser
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Application dismissed.
- No cost order was made.
- In favour of the respondent.
C. Esau
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Alleged Unfair Dismissal- Application dismissed.
- No cost order was made.
- In favour of the respondent.
NFC. Poggenpoel
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Respondent to appoint applicant
- No cost order was made.
- In favour of the applicant.
Y. Maans
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Application dismissed.
- No cost order was made.
- In favour of the respondent.
M. Marsh
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Settlement agreement.
N. Abrahams
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Respondent to appoint applicant
- No cost order was made.
- In favour of the applicant.
-
2008
-
Case Number
Parties Involved
Nature of dispute
Award / Outcome
Applicant
Respondent
J. Sigudla
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Application dismissed.
- No cost order was made.
- In favour of the respondent.
L.J. Muller
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Application dismissed.
- No cost order was made.
- In favour of the respondent.
K. Isaacs
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Application dismissed.
- No cost order was made.
- In favour of the respondent.
-
2007
-
Case Number
Parties Involved
Nature of dispute
Award / Outcome
Applicant
Respondent
C. Dhlamini
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Alleged Overpayment- Respondent is to pay compensation of R90 660.03 plus all other benefits.
- No cost order was made.
- In favour of the applicant.
J.I. Julius
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Alleged Unfair Dismissal- Application dismissed.
- In favour of the respondent.
S.M. Vos
WCED
Main Issue:
Alleged Unfair Discrimination
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Respondent to appoint applicant.
- No cost order was made.
- In favour of the applicant.
M.R.M. Bains
& 2 OthersWCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Application dismissed.
- No cost order was made.
- In favour of the respondent.
I.J. Fourie
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Incapacity Sick Leave- Application dismissed.
- No cost order was made.
- In favour of the respondent.
Koeleman & Venter
WCED
Main Issue:
Alleged Unfair Discrimination
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Respondent to appoint applicant.
- No cost order was made.
- In favour of the respondent.
-
2006
-
Case Number
Parties Involved
Nature of dispute
Award / Outcome
Applicant
Respondent
L. Mlonyeni
L. Ngwayi
M. KomaneWCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Application dismissed.
- No cost order was made.
- In favour of the respondent.
M.A. Myners
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Application dismissed.
- No cost order was made.
- In favour of the respondent.
W.C. Böhmer
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Application dismissed.
- No cost order was made.
- In favour of the respondent.
E. Jodwana
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Alleged Unfair Dismissal- Respondent to appoint applicant.
- No cost order was made.
- In favour of the applicant.
S Adams
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Non-renewal of fixed term contract- Respondent is to pay compensation of R 20 400,00
- No cost order was made
- In favour of the applicant
Y Basson
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Non-renewal of fixed term contract- Respondent is to pay compensation of R 20 400,00
- No cost order was made
- In favour of the applicant
L Liebenberg
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Non-renewal of fixed term contract- Respondent is to pay compensation of R 20 400,00
- No cost order was made
- In favour of the applicant
S Adams
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Non-renewal of fixed term contract- Respondent is to pay compensation of R 20 400,00
- No cost order was made
- In favour of the applicant
FL Williams
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Non-renewal of fixed term contract- Respondent is to pay compensation of R 20 400,00
- No cost order was made
- In favour of the applicant
CA Persence
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Non-renewal of fixed term contract- Respondent is to pay compensation of R 20 400,00
- No cost order was made
- In favour of the applicant
JJ Engelbrecht
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Non-renewal of fixed term contract- Respondent is to pay compensation of R 20 400,00
- No cost order was made
- In favour of the applicant
SA Herman
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Non-renewal of fixed term contract- Respondent is to pay compensation of R 20 400,00
- No cost order was made
- In favour of the applicant
CE Conradie
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Non-renewal of fixed term contract- Respondent is to pay compensation of R 20 400,00
- No cost order was made
- In favour of the applicant
EEG Pietersen
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Non-renewal of fixed term contract- Respondent is to pay compensation of R 20 400,00
- No cost order was made
- In favour of the applicant
DOG Muller
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Promotion- No cost order was made
- In favour of the respondent
DA Kotze
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Application dismissed
- In favour of the respondent
F Williams
WCED
Main Issue:
Alleged unfair dismissal
Sub Issue:
Non-renewal of contract- Repeat the short listing and inter-viewing process
- No cost order was made
- In favour of the applicant
JJ Markgraaf
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Provision of benefits- In favour of the respondent.
-
2005
-
Case Number
Parties Involved
Nature of dispute
Award / Outcome
Applicant
Respondent
ZC Molo
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Application dismissed.
- In favour of the respondent.
MA du Plessis
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Respondent to instruct SGB to repeat short listing and nomination process.
- The appointment of the current incumbent will either be confirmed or withdrawn by the respondent.
- No cost order was made.
AJ Sigudla
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- In favour of the applicant.
ED Theron
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Application dismissed.
- In favour of the respondent.
Windvogel
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Appointment / Promotion- Application dismissed.
- In favour of the respondent.
DF Claassen
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice- Application dismissed due to applicant’s absence.
- In favour of the respondent.
JD Prinsloo
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice- Applicant not entitled to any relief.
- No cost order was made.
MM Mtshemla
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Dismissal in terms of Section 14(1) of the EEA- Applicant’s dismissal in terms of section 14(1) of the EEA was both substantively and procedurally fair.
- In favour of the respondent.
ID Hartzentberg
WCED
Main Issue:
Unfair Labour Practice
Sub Issue:
Benefits- Application dismissed.
- In favour of the respondent.